The tenth and eleventh episodes of Season 1 of Hell’s Kitchen aired on Fox, on August 1st, 2005, as a double feature. On those episodes, Ralph and Michael designed their own restaurants, chose their brigade for the final service, and one of them was declared winner of Hell’s Kitchen.
Please watch the full episode before you read (below) to avoid spoilers about this episode.
Intro
The episode began with a recap of the first nine episodes of the season, mentioning what happened, and who got eliminated when.
That episode began at the exact point where the last one left off. Ralph and Michael got some appreciated time with their respective families after Jessica’s elimination. Back in the dorms, both talked on the patio while smoking cigarettes, telling they both dreamed about having their own restaurant.
New restaurant design
The next morning, the phone rang in the dorms and Ralph answered “Bonsoir!”. Ramsay told him to get in the dining room with Michael two minutes later, and when they hung up, Ramsay mocked Ralph’s “bonsoir”. Two minutes later, the finalists had a chat with Ramsay, where he announced the final test. After the chat, Ramsay made them stand up, one on each side of the restaurant, and a huge white blanket came down from the ceiling, which became their final test. Each contestant had to design their dream restaurant, with the help of John Janavs, the architect of Hell’s Kitchen, Jean-Philippe for the service, and the Sous Chefs for their menus. Michael took the red kitchen, and Ralph took the blue kitchen.
After a quick consultation with Janavs and Jean-Philippe, works in both restaurants started immediately. During the process, Janavs talked to Ralph about a problem, which was his wallpaper only came with half of what was needed. So, he reassured Ralph by telling him they would get a shipment from Pennsylvania to the airport that night. After that, Ramsay talked with Janavs and remarked that Michael’s restaurant seemed to have a very contemporary style, and Ralph’s to feel like a bistro-steakhouse. Janavs explained that those were the mood both contestants desired. Ramsay felt nervous, but Janavs reassured him.
Final challenge
Ramsay introduced the final challenge, which was the Final Signature Dish Challenge, by saying that everybody around the world go to restaurants to taste the signature dishes. Each contestant had to prepare the signature dish for their restaurant. Michael made a braised short rib oso buco, and Ralph made a Porto House steak for two people.
Both got on the Hollywood Walk of Fame with Ramsay to get customers taste both dishes. During the challenge, when he saw he was losing, Ralph started to panic and became like a salesman, trying to sell his food and telling that his food was better than Michael’s. One of the customers stated he was liking Michael’s dish more, but was liking Ralph more as a person. Michael won the challenge 12-6.
Restaurant design continuing
When both finalists returned to Hell’s Kitchen, they met John Janavs again, who told them that the works were doing great. Both contestants were satisfied with their new restaurants. Then, they returned to the kitchen to work on their food.
Practice service
The night before the final service, Ramsay made a practice service for Ralph and Michael where they would feed the construction workers of the restaurant, and where both would run the hot plate. On his first ticket, Michael had trouble to be heard by everybody because he was not talking loud enough. Ramsay told him he was not reading the dictionary at bedtime and had to be loud. Michael acknowledged his downfall, and a few minutes later, he turned around and jokingly told his team they were cooking like old people, which made Ramsay laugh because it was not expected.
After Michael’s turn, Ralph took his place. On his first ticket, he already seemed very confident and charismatic, which was praised later by Ramsay. However, he failed to spot Michael’s sabotage, which was crab risottos without crab. He was also calling Jean-Philippe “Jean-Pierre”. Construction workers started to complain, and a risotto came back. Ramsay told Ralph he had to taste everything. Ralph told Michael about his supposed mistake, and Ramsay acknowledged it was a clever move from Michael. After service, Ramsay was not impressed and detected many flaws from both contestants. Michael had to run the team and not the other way around, and Ralph had a poor-quality control.
When both got back to the dorms, Michael got into character by mimicking some Ramsay rants, which made Ralph laugh. After that, Michael went out on the patio and did his nightly ritual of speaking with Ramsay’s face on the billboard, while smoking a cigarette.
Restaurant design finish
After a good night’s sleep, Ralph and Michael got down in the dining room to see the progress of their new restaurants. Ralph was very satisfied and told by Janavs that the wallpaper problem has been solved. On the other hand, Michael had problems of his own because the booths he asked for did not came in time. Also, the beige color of the stairs’ base would not match those booths, so Michael agreed to switch the color from beige to red.
Team selection
When the finalists came back in the kitchen, Ramsay greeted them to their staff, which were returning contestants. Dewberry was the first who entered the room, followed by Wendy, Andrew, Jimmy, Elsie, and finally Jessica. Because Michael won the final challenge, he got to pick first. His first pick was Jessica, which infuriated Ralph because he felt Jessica was his. Jessica was not very happy about that decision either as she would have wanted to be on Ralph’s team. Ralph selected Andrew as his first pick, and Michael picked Jimmy as his second pick. Ralph picked Wendy as his second pick, Michael picked Elsie as his last, and Ralph was left with Dewberry. Dewberry was not angry about being picked last because he expected it.
Before service
During prep, Michael stated he would have preferred professional cooks instead of returning teammates, but had to deal with what he had. On the other side, Ralph made a list of rules to follow for his team. Jean-Philippe came to Ralph’s kitchen, and asked him, who called him “Jean-Pierre” once again, to come to the dining room and meet his dining room staff. He declared the name of his restaurant “Frank & Lulu’s”, referring to his dog’s name, and his friend’s dog’s name. Then, Michael met his staff and named his restaurant “Lola Pop”, referring to his wife’s pet name that he was giving to her. Later, Michael’s booths arrived, to his great relief.
An hour and a half before service, Andrew cut his thumb when peeling an artichoke. He showed his injury to a disgusted Wendy, went to see a medic, and was taken to the hospital. All that time, Andrew stated he did not want to let his team down. When Ralph went to see Ramsay in his office, he declared that being a man down, he would run the pass and the garnish station at the same time. Ramsay was not a fan of that process.
After that, Ramsay changed subject by having a look at Ralph’s restaurant to see the design and the staff. When Ralph introduced his staff to him, Ramsay said the men were looking great, but the women were looking like grannies. For Michael’s dining room, Ramsay liked its setting and vibe, and for the staff, remarked that girls were looking great, but guys were looking like ballerinas. Ramsay joked about it saying that the guys should go get their tutus. A few minutes before the doors open, Andrew made a heroic return, was hugged by Wendy and gave Ralph a high-five, to the latter’s relief. Michael and Ralph were given their head chef jackets, and briefed their teams.
Dinner service
Moments after the doors opened, Michael and Ralph gave each other a big hug. When Michael called his first ticket, his team was not answering immediately, so he had to told them they need to answer. It was a rocky start for him because he was lost and confused, and that made his team switch off completely and cooking as individuals. However, his first appetizers were well-received by the customers. In the blue kitchen, Ralph also got off to a bad start because of Wendy’s confusion on the appetizer station. She did not know how many orders she had to make, so Ralph spent more time on her station than the hot plate. But Ralph, being clever, had a backup plan, which was a tableside salad appetizer.
More than an hour into service, one of Michael’s customers had plastic in her salad. When it came back, Michael threatened Elsie to kill her if she would do it again. After, Jessica, still angry at not being on Ralph’s team, refused Michael’s authority and had a confrontation with Elsie. Michael had to calm the situation down. In the blue kitchen, the customers were enjoying the food, and Ralph started to send out entrées. But, Ralph caught Dewberry putting fish stock in the spaghetti when he was not supposed to, and Dewberry was almost passing out. After Dewberry left the kitchen, Ralph talked with Sous Chef Scott about that problem, worried that he would not make it through dinner service because of his physical state. Jean-Philippe also told Ralph that despite the food being great, the service had to go faster. Andrew got in the back store to check on Dewberry, who was sitting down, and pushed him to go through service. When Dewberry made a heroic return, Ralph held him the list of rules to follow, and Dewberry managed to bounce back after sending a properly cooked sea bass, while jokingly telling he would rather be called Brad Pitt’s wife. That joke made Ramsay, Ralph and Sous Chef Scott laugh.
Three hours into service, Ralph managed to get more than half of his entrées out successfully. When an undercooked steak came back in the red kitchen, Michael told Jimmy to refire one quickly, and that he was not happy about it. Jimmy successfully bounced back and sent an acceptable steak dish. It was at this moment that Michael’s kitchen started to come together as a proper professional kitchen. Both kitchens started to send out desserts, and had a great finish. After all the tables were completed in both dining room, Michael was congratulated by Jessica, who said the menu was easy to execute, and Dewberry was given a big kiss by Ralph.
Post-mortem
After both teams were lined up, Ramsay congratulated both saying it was a great service. When it seemed that Ramsay was ready to announce the winner, he told he was not ready and would study the comment cards from the customers to help him make his decision. Then, Ramsay declared that because Michael wanted a restaurant in Los Angeles, every customer in his restaurant was from Los Angeles, and that because Ralph wanted a New York Steakhouse, every of his customers were from New York.
Michael and Ralph congratulated each other as they made their way back to the dorms while knowing that their fate was in Ramsay’s hands. Ralph believed he might win, given that he was a little stronger than Michael, but Michael felt that he deserved to win, given he was representing the new generation of chefs and that he pushed himself in service. Then, both split off to different rooms, each hoping that they would be the winners, while talking to the photos of their loved ones.
Winner Announced
Moments later, Sous Chefs Scott and Mary-Ann came to the dorms, put blindfolds on Michael and Ralph, and told them to put their hands on their back so they could lead them to Ramsay’s office. Arrived there, Ramsay declared that one of the two restaurants received a 90% of return business, and the other one got 94%. After that, he asked both to stand in front of a door each, and said that only the winner’s door would open. After waiting nervously for Ramsay’s countdown to end, both finalists turned their handles, and only Michael’s door opened.
Michael became the first winner of Hell’s Kitchen, and Ralph the first runner-up. Ralph took his defeat graciously and celebrated with everybody else. While celebrating, Ramsay made an offer to Michael, which was to come to London to train under him and eventually become a world-class chef, an offer which Michael accepted.
Ramsay’s comment: “Ralph was great tonight, but Michael deserved to win because his creativity and standards are simply on a higher level, and I accomplish my goal of turning an unknown into a master chef and that has to be the perfect way to close Hell’s Kitchen, tonight. And I’m fucking out of here!”
My options
My comments: Michael team was better than Ralph because Ralph got the second pick because Michael won the challenge so Ralph got Dewberry and Wendy the first two to go out of all of the chefs who come back.

